| ||||||
| All In One Spirit 2010 College Football Game of the Year Award winner | | | Champions 2009 College Football Game of the Year Award winner | ||
| ||||||
| ||||||
| Appalachian State 2007 College Football Game of the Year Award winner | | | Rutgers 2006 College Football Game of the Year Award winner | ||
| ||||||
| ||||||
| College Football Game of the Year Award | |||||
|